Quote from: BoxCrayonTales on May 13, 2024, 03:01:02 PMOK, so what they did with their property hurt your feelings and you want to lash out against them in impotent rage. Sorry you feel that way.Quote from: GeekyBugle on May 13, 2024, 12:22:57 PMRe: The players don't care about the lore...There are different ways that people enjoy lore. After seeing it self-destruct dozens of times in every single IP I ever showed interest in, and being cyberbullied by lore worshipers in some fandoms, I no longer give a flying fuck about lore. These writers don't give a fuck about their continuity, and toxic fans use it as an excuse to bully people for wrongthink, so why should I care? Bring on the multiverse shenanigans!
There's so much wrong with this
The two "oldest" and biggest wargames today are WH40K & Battletech, what do they have in common? Deep lore.
The lore sells itself and the game and plastic, try introducing a new faction by just dropping the army books with pure stats.
Now even OPR Grimdark Future has it's first lore book. Guess they all failed market research.
Quote from: BadApple on May 13, 2024, 05:25:03 AMQuote from: Slipshot762 on May 13, 2024, 02:43:17 AMInteresting to me is the lore surrounding how magic users are regarded. What is that dividing line between "muh court whyzhard" and "burn her before she turns us all into newts!" I've often wondered?
Historically you had magicians like dee and kelly, who worked for the crown as magicians, known to be engaged with divining contact with angels to learn from them the enochian language, the language of creation, in order to work magic...the whole thing appearing to have the approval of both government and heaven, as opposed the hated reviled witch or sorceror in lore.
I suppose it likely has something to do with the nature of the practices in question; if man is given earthly dominion by god then it would be contradictory to serve or deal with as equals any demons, devils, undead, entities, or spirits...yet it would seem there is an implication i am detecting which says that conjuring an old bitch-devil and beating it into submission with your wand in the name of god and making it teach you featherfall is perfectly ok or something.
Never quite nailed this down but thats the best i came up with.
In Christian tradition, any use of magic is considered a contract with the devil. There were no officially recognized court mages in Christian European nations. This is also true in Islamic countries. There was no distinction between witches and great wizards, they were all sinners in need of burning. Many western magic users practiced in secret, always afraid of getting caught.
Quote from: jeff37923 on May 13, 2024, 12:44:49 PMIs any of Dark Dungeons useful or did the rot set in back then? I was thinking of grabbing a copy.
Quote from: WERDNA on December 19, 2023, 01:21:07 AMQuote from: RPGPundit on December 19, 2023, 01:10:56 AMSome of my Pundit Files issues were going to feature these monsters.
Exciting to hear. I'm sure you'll do better than Oriental Adventures did with them (not that I blame them, research would've been harder back then). ...Wait, why past tense?
Quote from: Zelen on May 13, 2024, 09:22:41 PMMy stance is that lore is incredibly important, but anyone who cares about lore at this point should see the writing on the wall for Battletech.
It's a lot less damaging for "the lore" to accept a spin-off with renamed factions + characters that keeps the underlying themes, tone, style, than to continue on supporting a game/IP which is compromised by malicious actors whose expressed goals are to subvert that story/setting.