I figured we should do this pre-Mythic Adventures. Just a gut feeling.

Some potential nominees:

Ultimate Magic
Ultimate Combat
Ultimate Raaacist
Ultimate NPCs
Ultimate Golarion

You know, anything really. I don't currently have a nominee, since I've been playing 3.5 lately and haven't looked at any of my Paizo stuff in a while.

It's been a while since I looked, but how about "Humans of Golarion". It recycles content and art from the Golarion setting book which I'd assume anyone buying "Humans of Golarion" already has.

This thread really has no value at all.

Quote from: Archangel Fascist;683258This thread really has no value at all.

Huh? Are you suggesting that every single Pathfinder book is precisely of equal quality?

Any books that recycle are good candidates.  Magnimar's city book is an example I have used before.

But for me, Ultimate Combat can be hard to swallow.  It makes the assumption that ninjas are appropriate for PCs in a fantasy setting. It makes the assumption that guns are appropriate for a fantasy setting.  Bonus points for putting them in the same book.

Quote from: RPGPundit;683782Huh? Are you suggesting that every single Pathfinder book is precisely of equal quality?

No, I'm saying that the OP posted a shitty trollish thread.

Quote from: Archangel Fascist;683845No, I'm saying that the OP posted a shitty trollish thread.

What makes it a troll thread? Just that its not pro-paizo?

QuoteI figured we should do this pre-Mythic Adventures. Just a gut feeling.

He's nominated all recent Paizo publications and complaining about an as-to-be released book.  The thread is just him saying, "Paizo sucks."

Quote from: FASERIP;683108Ultimate Raaacist

For obvious reasons the book is called Advanced Race Guide.

But yes, Humans of Golarion.

Well, it's third party, but I nominate Fursona. Fucking mess. And I say this as someone who would unironically love to play D&D with a bunch of anthro races instead of the usual Tolkien crowd.

Quote from: mcbobbo;683789Any books that recycle are good candidates.  Magnimar's city book is an example I have used before.

But for me, Ultimate Combat can be hard to swallow.  It makes the assumption that ninjas are appropriate for PCs in a fantasy setting. It makes the assumption that guns are appropriate for a fantasy setting.  Bonus points for putting them in the same book.

I agree on UC. I'm not against ninja or gunslingers per se, but they have no place in my games 99% of the time.

Quote from: LibraryLass;684350Well, it's third party, but I nominate Fursona. Fucking mess. And I say this as someone who would unironically love to play D&D with a bunch of anthro races instead of the usual Tolkien crowd.

Well, not to be a dick, but with a name like that, did you really expect anything better?

Or do you not recognize the term?

Quote from: J Arcane;684363Well, not to be a dick, but with a name like that, did you really expect anything better?

Or do you not recognize the term?

Could we just pretend both the term and the book don't exist.

*Shudder*

Quote from: J Arcane;684363Well, not to be a dick, but with a name like that, did you really expect anything better?

Or do you not recognize the term?

No, I do. But once in a while something specifically targeted at furries turns out okay, and I let myself hope this was one such time. I was horribly wrong.

Quote from: Archangel Fascist;684299He's nominated all recent Paizo publications and complaining about an as-to-be released book.  The thread is just him saying, "Paizo sucks."

This.

That being said, his forgone assumption that Mythic Adventures implicitly sucks is false in my book. To be fair, this is somewhat to my surprise. It's basically just a book of "moar powars", but I find the campaign context that comes with it just intriguing enough to pique my interest. And it seems like it will work much better that 3.5 ELH. It's a bit more along the lines of gestalt classes in 3.5 UA than ELH.

Of Paizo supplements I have (given that I don't buy all the Golarian books), Ultimate Magic is probably the biggest letdown, mainly because it devotes a huge chapter to a magic system I will never use (nor will it appear or get use in any AP, I imagine).

I don't use Ninja, Samurai, or Gunslinger, but I don't see that as a black mark. These sorts of supplements should be approached as tools for the GM to build the world, not a buffet for the player. I'm not using any of those classes in my current games, but I could see using them in the right sort of campaign.