This is a site for discussing roleplaying games. Have fun doing so, but there is one major rule: do not discuss political issues that aren't directly and uniquely related to the subject of the thread and about gaming. While this site is dedicated to free speech, the following will not be tolerated: devolving a thread into unrelated political discussion, sockpuppeting (using multiple and/or bogus accounts), disrupting topics without contributing to them, and posting images that could get someone fired in the workplace (an external link is OK, but clearly mark it as Not Safe For Work, or NSFW). If you receive a warning, please take it seriously and either move on to another topic or steer the discussion back to its original RPG-related theme.

Author Topic: Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks  (Read 8421 times)

S'mon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13315
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« on: July 03, 2018, 05:59:51 AM »
(from my blog, a little rant)

Inspired by common recommendations to use it as a GM's first 5e adventure, I have to say I disagree.

The problems start with the very first encounter, and what it says about the world.

Why are 4 goblins ambushing a well armed party of 4-6 larger and likely tougher looking travellers - the PCs?  Answer: To give PCs a starting encounter. From goblin perspective it makes no sense. They would let such go past & wait for easier prey.

Why do the goblins use such sub-optimal tactics, with 2 charging into melee to get slaughtered? Answer: So the PCs can win. Because if the goblins were to use sniping tactics from cover, combined with their racial ability to hide, disengage etc, they might well actually win.

This is a terrible first encounter which sends the message that the world exist for the benefit of the PCs. It would work much better to (for instance) have four drunken goblins lounging around the wagon Paizo-style, a wine butt spilling the last dregs onto the ground - ie the PCs got lucky. Then the goblins can even react in confused & suboptimal manner without straining plausibility.

But don't set up an ambush that is suicidal from the POV of the ambushers.

Mike the Mage

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 633
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #1 on: July 03, 2018, 07:41:18 AM »
Quote from: S'mon;1046996
Why do the goblins use such sub-optimal tactics, with 2 charging into melee to get slaughtered? Answer: So the PCs can win.

WotC writers metagaming a touch, I see.
When change threatens to rule, then the rules are changed

Nerzenjäger

  • Gefechtsösterreicher
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 587
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #2 on: July 03, 2018, 08:04:33 AM »
Suboptimal goblin tactics are now the reason the whole of Mines of Phandelver sucks? K, fam.
« Last Edit: July 03, 2018, 08:11:23 AM by Nerzenjäger »
"You play Conan, I play Gandalf.  We team up to fight Dracula." - jrients

estar

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10065
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #3 on: July 03, 2018, 08:35:51 AM »
The adventure is written for up to five PCs not six, it on page 2 first sentence of Running the Adventure. If you run it with six or more then their advice and setup indeed doesn't make sense and the PCs will handily win most encounters.

I have run Philanderer three times, each time the initial goblin ambush was challenge for the PC. Two reasons their high stealth resulted in a surprise round each time and they are armed with shortbows.

This blog post, a near party kill, is typical of how the first encounter goes for me.

As for in-game motivation, the adventure has the party driving a wagon full of supplies to Phandelver. Out of a five person party may be one or two will looked like a heavily armed warrior. The rest will be dressed in more ordinary clothes little different than what commoner wear. The party in my blog post only Vognur looked like a armed warrior. Sidwin had some gear and looked like he could handle himself in a fight. But Squirrel was dressed in ordinary clothes and Ara was dressed in robes that marked him as slightly more wealthy.

The goblins also have a wisdom of 8 which implies they would tend to take more chances than a more sensible group would. Combined with the overconfidence resulting from their use of missile weapons and stealth ability to me makes an ambush of a 4 to 5 person party involved escorting a supply wagon makes it a plausible encounter.

Is the setup and advice perfect? No but I still give a solid A as far as these goes. However also from experience running 5e, if you have less than four or more than five, then the encounter will likely go very different when run multiple times. I don't think the writer of the adventure realized how crucial that is.

Especially in hindsight when 5e first came out a lot of people wanted to try it. This often resulted in oversized parties. So if I were to write a intro adventure like Phandelver for the next hot edition, I would spend some paragraph on how to scale encounters up (or down) to account for the size of the party. I am not a fan of scaling but the point of Phandelver is an aide to the novice referee. They need to know what the effect of having a 8 person party swamp everything or what happens if there are only two players involved.

Armchair Gamer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • A
  • Posts: 3009
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #4 on: July 03, 2018, 08:54:25 AM »
I played through Lost Mine of Phandelver, and for some reason, I didn't find it all that engaging. Maybe I'm just not suited to D&D.

Brad

  • Semper Qvantvm Potes
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3630
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #5 on: July 03, 2018, 09:19:25 AM »
It's an entry level adventure for newbie players; it's supposed to teach the mechanics. Did you ever play the Mentzer Red Box adventure? You pretty much are guaranteed to beat the first couple encounters by design.
It takes considerable knowledge just to realize the extent of your own ignorance.

Azraele

  • Smug bastard
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 545
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #6 on: July 03, 2018, 09:41:53 AM »
I went to your blog in hopes your full review delved deeper

It didn't. This is the entire review

One would think, as we're D&D players, that we'd explore our dungeons a little deeper
Joel T. Clark: Proprietor of the Mushroom Press, Member of the Five Emperors
Buy Lone Wolf Fists! https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/416442/Tian-Shang-Lone-Wolf-Fists

MonsterSlayer

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 402
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #7 on: July 03, 2018, 10:15:11 AM »
You give goblins too many street smarts and too little confidence in their stealth abilities.

Plus there is that whole (very subtle) plot point about the goblins being on the look out for anyone with mining supplies and the bugbear back at the lair ready to kick their asses if they do not obey.

(SPOILER)

I think it is kind of assumed these are the same goblins that ambushed the dwarf earlier and confidence is high on the goblin side.

Plus, (and here is where I think you really miss the boat on Phandelver) not every first time D&D player is a tactical genius or looking to play D&D Risk. Some of them just want to pretend to be an Elf that goes Pew Pew every now and then. And WoTC wants them to feel welcome too. You as the experienced DM should be able to flavor to taste.

Haffrung

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • H
  • Posts: 5155
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #8 on: July 03, 2018, 10:47:50 AM »
Phandelver isn't awful, but it isn't nearly as good as many 5E fans would have us believe. It presents a few mini-dungeons and a very basic, vanilla plot. The challenges ramp up. They take place in varied environments. It's hard to screw up the adventure.

On the minus side, it's generic Forgotten Realms pablum. When the PCs get to town, they're confronted with a gang of ruffians and one solution to the problem - hack them all dead. The villain does nothing villainous; he's the villain because he's the villain (and Glassstaff? Really? Even by the dire standards of FR, that's bad). A bunch of vanilla NPCs are introduced but they can be pretty much ignored. The town is and its inhabitants are far less interesting than Hommlet. The dungeons are generic complexes. It's all safe and boring and accessible and uninspired.

Really, it's a testament to how modest our expectations are for low-level published adventures that Phandelver gets so much praise.
 

Armchair Gamer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • A
  • Posts: 3009
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #9 on: July 03, 2018, 10:53:42 AM »
Quote from: Haffrung;1047031
Phandelver isn't awful, but it isn't nearly as good as many 5E fans would have us believe. It presents a few mini-dungeons and a very basic, vanilla plot. The challenges ramp up.

  That might explain why I found it underwhelming--we came in with 3rd and 4th level characters converted from BECMI, so we were overleveled for most of it.

Motorskills

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • M
  • Posts: 1055
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #10 on: July 03, 2018, 10:57:29 AM »
LMoP is littered with problems, not least the opening skirmish.

Still a fantastic intro module.
“Gosh it’s so interesting (profoundly unsurprising) how men with all these opinions about women’s differentiation between sexual misconduct, assault and rape reveal themselves to be utterly tone deaf and as a result, systemically part of the problem.” - Minnie Driver, December 2017

" Using the phrase "virtue signalling" is 'I'm a sociopath' signalling ". J Wright, July 2018

Shawn Driscoll

  • Role-Play Purist
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2928
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #11 on: July 03, 2018, 11:00:53 AM »
All the monsters die in D&D though. All hobo serial killer games suck, in general.

Azraele

  • Smug bastard
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 545
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #12 on: July 03, 2018, 11:13:58 AM »
Quote from: Shawn Driscoll;1047039
All the monsters die in D&D though. All hobo serial killer games suck, in general.

God I want to game with you. You're just so optimistic!
Joel T. Clark: Proprietor of the Mushroom Press, Member of the Five Emperors
Buy Lone Wolf Fists! https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/416442/Tian-Shang-Lone-Wolf-Fists

Brad

  • Semper Qvantvm Potes
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3630
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #13 on: July 03, 2018, 11:37:05 AM »
Quote from: Shawn Driscoll;1047039
All the monsters die in D&D though. All hobo serial killer games suck, in general.

Have you ever actually played D&D before? Serious question.
It takes considerable knowledge just to realize the extent of your own ignorance.

Steven Mitchell

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • S
  • Posts: 3772
Why Lost Mine of Phandelver Sucks
« Reply #14 on: July 03, 2018, 11:48:30 AM »
Phandelver could have used a little more of the fantastical, and a little more varied situations.  However, it is constrained by being a teaching module.  There is even somewhat of a mini-railroad at the beginning so that the instructions in that section are used first.  The main problem thereafter is that that environment is sparse.