1
Pen and Paper Roleplaying Games (RPGs) Discussion / Re: Have we been calculating hit points wrong since the beginning? I think so...
« Last post by Domina on Today at 10:05:36 PM »
I have. It is possible to interpret the rule that way, since I interpreted it that way, so I remain correct. Posturing as a bizarrely aggressive sperg because you believe your position is popular is not an argument.
I'm not making a populous argument. What you are talking about about would almost instantly break the game.
You were making an argument from popularity, since you told me to "get friends", even though it doesn't matter if zero people agree with me or a hundred trillion.
Whether it's game breaking depends entirely on the opposition selected by the GM.
I have. It is possible to interpret the rule that way, since I interpreted it that way, so I remain correct. Posturing as a bizarrely aggressive sperg because you believe your position is popular is not an argument.
I'm not making a populous argument. What you are talking about about would almost instantly break the game.
What level did your campaign play into? Level 5, 10, higher?
What version of D&D were you using?
hook, line, and sinker
Disagreement is not trolling. If you don't have anything to contribute, don't post.
I have. It is possible to interpret the rule that way, since I interpreted it that way, so I remain correct. Posturing as a bizarrely aggressive sperg because you believe your position is popular is not an argument.
You have not interpreted it that way. You have instead made up something that is directly contradicted by the text. You do this in a lot of rules threads just to start drama with people who are correct. I'm not sure if you're trolling or earnestly incorrect.
I interpreted it that way. Don't tell me what I did or didn't do. Disagreeing with people is not starting drama, and you're not the arbiter of which positions are correct.
I said what I said, which was go play the game with your friends and you'll see how ridiculous it is to add the HD each level. Simple as that.
No, you were very obviously trying to imply that I don't have friends and don't actually play the game (never mind that I would still be right regardless). I have friends, we have played the game, and we haven't seen that it is ridiculous, and you will not win the argument by attempting to dictate which experiences are reasonable to have.