Well, this guy was banned for pointing out a perfectly sane thing: that children should be removed from toxic/dangerous environments and be allowed to grow up in safe ones. I believe that this is the law in almost - if not all - the developed countries and it is the job of social services to monitor the situation.
He then muses if a little orc is removed from a toxic environment (like Sauron's shadow) he will be able to grow up and not being evil.
I mean... This is as "progressive" as it gets. Why the ban, then?
Because you can "associate" (arbitrarily) the
general idea to something bad that happened in the past (and to specific countries/cultures - I never heard before about Residential Schools maybe because I'm not Canadian).
By this reasoning, I'll be able to ban someone who approves if social services remove a kid from a toxic/dangerous environment. Why?
Because there are people out there who "liberate" underage girls from their parents, keep them prisoners for years or even decades, sometimes have sons with them, and at the end maybe kill them - all in name of bettering these girls' lifes. So...
"You propose that social services help kids living in dangerous environments by... taking them and bringing them elsewhere?! HOW DO YOU DARE TO PROPOSE SOMETHING SO SIMILAR TO A TERRIBLE CRIME, YOU HORRIFIC PERVERT!?"
---> PermaBan
These guys are not realising that they are losing their very own moral compasses. I guess that they are not even able to
think anymore.