BEWARE - MAJOR SPOILERS HERE
Okay, I've only seen up to the end of season 3, haven't seen any of season 4.
In the last episode season 3, I take it they're saying Tigh, Chief, Starbuck's hubby, the president's aide, and Starbuck are the final 5 cylons, right? I'm having a problem with that timeline, particularly with Tigh. It looked to me from Razor that the cylons were just starting to experiment with biologicals and such (the first hybrid). Tigh fought in the first cylon war, right? So how is he a cylon (if he is)? Plus, most of the others would have to have been cylons from birth based on some of their flashbacks.
If you know the answers, go ahead and spoil it for me.
Also, WTF was that with All Along the Watchtower? Are they trying to say Bob Dylan is from outer space or something, because I guess you could argue that? But really, they had better explain that and it better have something to do with earth, otherwise their credibility with me just took a serious hit. They could have just as easily introduced a new poem or song.
Pete