Not really. It's not as though there haven't been earlier threads about PCs committing atrocities (rapes, mass murders, necrophilia) in other RPGs, most of which haven't been threatened with lockdowns either; and as I pointed out over there, there doesn't seem to be anything particularly offensive in Poison'd itself that you couldn't find in, say, WoD. The common opinion over the years has consistently been that the consent of everyone at the table and respecting the boundaries which they don't want crossed are the most important factors when dealing with potentially disturbing topics, and I agree with that. It's all about what the group brings to the game.
Moral relativism at it's finest.
Why is it that people who claim there should not be such an uproar can't leave these threads alone? I mean, there were a couple of posts and the OP - but you, GrimGent, just couldn't let it go.
If everyone who said they don't care acted like it, would there be 600 post threads?
The common opinion? Over the years?
Whose common opinion? Over which years?
I hereby proclaim that common wisdom over many years states that there are lines which, when crossed, mean the group is fucked in the head.
See how that works? You don't believe it any more than I believe your hack claim about "common opinion."
It's an opinion you are not likely to change. And as much as it might drive pseudoephedrine crazy, it's probably best to just agree to disagree and promise not to game together...