How many Americans here believe the U.S. is uniquely free, has unique opportunities, etc., and how widespread is the notion among Americans at large?
I trend in that direction. I think it's less now than, say, 40 years ago - both as a result of our slide and others' gains. but I still think we hold an edge. Let me put it this way, I think we are unique, but I don't know that we're the best in freedom or opportunity. It's a rare mix we have; that I would support.
Is it true that America is unlike other nations in embodying universal ideals, particularly freedom in speech and politics, and in economic opportunity?
I think that last is probably still our forte. I think, as I mentioned, we're less exceptional on the speech and politics. That's all implementation or execution. I do think we continue to be unmatched in our idealism. Whether we reach those lofty peaks or not is a different question - and we must always remember the road to hell is paved with good intentions...
How does the widely held belief in American exceptionalism among Americans affect America's relations with the rest of the world?
I disagree with Kyle (surprise!) and say it's not so unique in the world. What we do have is the economic and military power to act on that belief in exceptionalism, which I'm sure does not sit well with others.
Then again, if we ever wanted to fight when I was in school in Milwaukee, all we had to do was tell them they were a suburb of Chicago. It's the little brother syndrome, to some extent. To shift Mr. Gleichman's point a little - until we cease to be the, or one of the, superpowers of the world, there will be a certain level of hostility.
And I understand it - I can empathize with those that feel we are telling them how to live when they didn't ask us to be in charge. Taxation without Representation, indeed.